Most categories are more commoditized than the people inside them realize. When the products are nearly identical, the supply chains overlap, and the pricing converges within a few percent, the tactical levers most marketing teams reach for (paid media, promo cadence, landing page optimization) deliver smaller and smaller returns over time. They still matter. They just stop being differentiators.
What remains is the brand. Not the logo or the color palette. The mental model your customer holds about what kind of company you are, and what that means about how they should feel when they choose you.
The math of commoditization
A useful way to test how commoditized your category is: ask yourself what changes if you raise prices 8%.
In a differentiated brand position, you lose some price-sensitive customers but retain the ones who chose you for reasons beyond price. In a commoditized category, you lose almost everyone, because the customer's decision is dominated by price and convenience.
When that's true, the operational levers (faster shipping, better packaging, slightly better photography) deliver incremental gains. The strategic lever (a clear brand position the customer can verbalize) is what changes the slope of the line.
What strong positioning actually does
A brand position isn't a tagline. It's the answer to four questions a customer asks, often subconsciously, before they buy.
Who is this for? Specifically. Not "everyone." If you can't name a customer segment your product is wrong for, your position isn't sharp enough.
What's the alternative? Customers always compare. If you can't name what they're comparing you to and why you win that comparison, neither can they.
What changes if I pick you? Functional change is table stakes. Emotional change is the differentiator. What do they feel afterward that they couldn't feel before?
Why should I believe you? Proof. Specifics. Evidence. Not testimonials. Hard reasons your claim is true.
If your About page, your homepage hero, and your top-of-funnel ad creative don't answer all four within five seconds of attention, you don't have a position. You have aspirations.
Why this is harder than it sounds
The temptation in commoditized categories is to position around features. "We're faster." "We're cheaper." "We have more SKUs." Feature positions are the most fragile kind, because every claim becomes obsolete the moment a competitor matches it.
Stronger positions are built around one of three things.
A specific customer. "Built for [narrowly defined customer]." The specificity creates the moat. Brands like Patagonia, Stripe, and Liquid Death didn't widen the target to grow. They went narrower than seemed reasonable, then dominated that narrow audience first.
A specific belief. "We believe [thing the industry doesn't]." Basecamp's "calm work." Public Goods' "transparent ingredients." The belief filters who buys and aligns the team.
A specific tension. "We do [X] without [Y you usually have to accept]." Allbirds: stylish without environmental cost. Warby Parker: prescription glasses without ridiculous markups. The tension creates urgency.
The deeper you commit to one of those positions, the more customers self-select. The trade-off is real. You lose the customers who don't fit. That's the point.
What to do this quarter
If you suspect your category has commoditized and your marketing is grinding for diminishing returns, here's a useful sequence.
Audit your competitor set's positioning. Print the hero copy from your top six competitors' homepages. Highlight everything that's interchangeable. The leftover differentiators are where the white space lives.
Talk to ten current customers. Specifically: customers who could have chosen anyone else and chose you. Ask why, in their words. Patterns will emerge. Those patterns are the seed of your real position, not the one you wrote.
Pick a position you can defend for three years. Positions need time. The brands that stand out picked something specific and held it through several cycles. The ones that rebrand every 18 months have no equity.
Pressure-test it across every touchpoint. Site copy, email, packaging, paid creative, sales calls, customer support tone. A position that doesn't show up everywhere reads as a marketing department exercise. The position has to be visible in operations, not just messaging.
The harder truth
Most commoditized businesses don't lose because their brand is weak. They lose because their brand decision is delegated.
A strong position requires the CEO to choose what the company is and isn't, and then defend that choice when growth slows or a competitor pulls a stunt. If positioning is going to live somewhere other than the marketing team's planning doc, it has to be a decision the leadership team made, signed, and resourced. Brand work that lives in the marketing silo never holds.
Written by C40 Digital. We publish about once a month. No filler, one click to unsubscribe. Subscribe.